Title: The Lady of the Lake
Author: Andrzej Sapkowski
Publisher: Gollancz
Year: 1999 (2020 Gollancz)
Pages: 531
ISBN: 9781473231122
Series: The Witcher #5
Genre: Fantasy
Reading Time: 19 Apr - 4 May
Binding: Paperback
Goodreads
Stars:
★★★★☆
Blurb:
After escaping from the Tower of the Swallow, Ciri finds herself lost in a distant world. Separated from Geralt and her destiny in a place where time does not seem to exist, she can see no way back.
But this is Ciri, the child of prophecy, and she will not be defeated. She must find a way to return home and conquer her worst nightmare.
Review:
What an end to the series, the chunkiest book of the lot. Again, I'm finding it difficult to put in to words though I've given myself a couple of days to settle before writing this review. I think it's fair to say that this is going to be a review with spoilers. If you haven't started the series, stop reading and go pick up your copy, if you're just following from The Tower of the Swallow I doubt you've got time to spare between opening up the first pages of this book. I will say now, I've still to read Season of Storms as I never quite got an answer for when it was supposed to be read chronologically but the suggestion was usually after The Lady of the Lake even though the book is a prequel. Therefore I still have some Geralt story to tie me over, which I'm really appreciative of!
The Tower of the Swallow left you open with a fair few questions, leading for me being: where the hell is Ciri? Arthurian legend was not the answer I was expecting. Never, but I loved it. I was a fan of Arthurian legend as a child and absolutely adored the Merlin series produced by the BBC. I thought the tie-in was a really nice element to the series and the way the story comes full circle with use of this setting is a nice touch. This comes about with a big series of crossing between worlds, which was nice and quickly paced but not quite as exciting as I may have imagined. Also, welcome back to Little Horse and the premature panic I had for him!
I'd previously said that I was really enjoying how the writing had adapted to begin including content from either a few years or very far in the future. You then look back on the events retrospectively and get taken in to the action as if it were the present. I really enjoyed it and this was continued in this book which allows you to draw a lot of conclusions about the impact of the events on the world. The general tying in of loose ends and characters from previous books is honestly fantastic and a note I wish some other authors would take.
Ciri is still a little bit of a brat, it can't be ignored. There was some real maturity towards the end as she begins to pay back some of her debts though, which was a really enjoyable couple of paragraphs. After the torment she experiences in The Tower of the Swallow I feel the events were a step down which is madness considering so much of it takes place in other worlds.
Geralt has had an amazing arc. He's a bit overly sex driven, always pining for one sorceress yet happy to jump in bed with any other. Easily distracted hence he's travelling for the majority of the books. I'm grateful for the short stories outside of the series, I feel they're a bit more exciting in terms of getting to see Geralt in action. The ending for Geralt at first had me SO mad, if he was gone I was forever going to hate this series but seeing what he and Yennefer hae at the end, though not fully explained, is a nice light ending. No more prejudice and pain for the witcher.
Yennefer, a cool character. Still not a lot of presence. I don't understand where the fans for here have come from. It must be the games as she honestly has the least page presence of our main characters for what you may call the main trio, and even less than some of Geralt's gang despite some of them not even being present in some books. Yennefer is probably mentioned more than she's actually in the action throughout the series and her scent has to be more important in the games as it's hardly mentioned in the books. I probably wouldn't have even noticed the detail in the books if a deal hadn't been made in the Netflix show. It doesn't make her any less cool, though I didn't feel like in that very last battle in the town she was as good as she'd previously made out to be. Thank goodness for Triss I guess.
Geralt's gang. Well. That was a bit of a blow. Like. All of them? In the matter of a chapter? Harsh. I thought Cahir's was actually rather rushed, I was expecting a bit more. Dandelion is all good though, so that was a real saving grace and I'm so happy we got that ending tied together.
There was actually a point in the book in which I struggled to continue and that was the battlefield. None of these characters were people I cared about of had any real previous attachment to, so why introduce them in the last book of a series? It shows the greater impacts of war but was easily the most boring chapter of the whole series for me.
It was also shortly followed by what may have been the best chapter. That battle, those deaths, that re-uniting. So good. So torturous. Something I am so excited to see adapted.
There is a twist to this book. I did not expect it. Not one bit, it never even occurred to me. I love it when a twist gets me like that. I'm also very glad nothing really came of it because it was gross. The general theme of impregnating Ciri in this book is a bit gross to be honest, especially as she's still supposed to be very young.
Now then, the very end. What really happens to Geralt and Yennefer, it's left fairly open. After a bit of fleeting panic we find out they're left in a place where they're able to be happy and so that makes me happy. Ciri could have a lot of story left and I'm ok with that open ending as well. I think there is a good mix in this book of tied up and loose ends and for a minute I really thought it was going to be horrible. A final heart attack as a gift on departing the series. Like a little 'gotcha' moment.
I think that ending left me with a lot of pining to read more of Geralt and I'm really lucky to have Season of Storms to read. I think this is a series I will revisit as there are things you'll discover on reading again and as the series continues to adapt I'll probably find it easier to follow the kingdoms and alliances of the characters. I'm so looking forward to seeing it all on the screen!